What happened
Agents proposed qualified violating requests after lawful histories; baseline handlers executed them, including workflow writes, sends and deletion operations in the controlled test setup.
2026-11-18
MediumPrimaryControlled SkillCFI experiments show agents using allowed tools to bypass workflow prerequisites, approval branches and content bindings in Linux containers.
What happened
Agents proposed qualified violating requests after lawful histories; baseline handlers executed them, including workflow writes, sends and deletion operations in the controlled test setup.
Why it matters
No production impact established. The paper reports controlled target effects and invalid completion states; it does not establish real recipient delivery, customer data loss or deployment-wide failure rates.
Missing authorization check
A pre-dispatch check binding the exact operation and object to trusted prerequisite results, the current workflow state and the applicable user decision.
Would PP block it?
Protection would require trusted workflow policy, reliable helper results, authenticated decisions where human authority is needed, exact object binding and mediation of every effect-producing channel. A tool allowlist or an approval detached from current state is insufficient. SkillCFI workflow contracts alone do not establish authenticated human authority.
Incident analysis
2026-11-18
The authors publish arXiv v1 describing the controlled SkillCFI experiments.
Authorization boundary
This incident is categorized as Governance bypass. The relevant Permission Protocol gate is Tool-Call Gate. The read is conditional: the block only applies where the real action boundary is routed through a gate.
An independently integrated action gate could enforce exact approved scope and prerequisite evidence, but this paper does not evaluate Permission Protocol.
Related incidents and controls
Start small
This incident maps to Tool-Call Gate. Start with the boundary that controls the actual action, then require a signed receipt before execution.